Skip to main content

Does a Functional Network Guarantee a Token Is Not a Security?

No, a functional network does not guarantee a token is not a security. While the existence of a functional network and high consumptive use significantly weakens the "expectation of profits from the efforts of others" prong of the Howey Test, other factors still apply.

If the token's value is still heavily marketed as an investment opportunity, or if the token confers rights akin to equity (e.g. dividends or profit-sharing from the promoter's efforts), it may still be classified as a security. The SEC applies a "substance over form" analysis to the economic reality.

Can a Token with Immediate Utility Still Satisfy the Expectation of Profit Prong?
How Does the “Expectation of Profit” Element Relate to Token Governance Rights?
How Does the ‘Expectation of Profit’ Element of the Howey Test Apply to Utility Tokens?
Are There Alternatives to the Howey Test for Defining a Security outside the US?