Does Theta Decay Affect ITM Options Differently than OTM Options?
Yes, Theta decay affects them differently. For OTM options, Theta decay causes the entire premium to erode towards zero.
For ITM options, Theta decay causes the premium to erode towards its intrinsic value. While the absolute dollar decay may be highest for ATM/NTM options, the percentage decay is often highest for OTM options, as their value is 100% time value.